Federal Reserve communication line dispute: Paulson advocates “clear communication”, Walsh insists on “not giving guidance”

Zhitongcaijing · 2d ago

The Zhitong Finance App learned that Philadelphia Federal Reserve Chairman Anna Paulson said at an event in New York on Thursday that it is essential for policymakers to clearly communicate about economic conditions and interest rate expectations at specific times. “When communication works and we understand each other, interest rates can better guide spending in the right direction; the Commission can handle temporary shocks without harming credibility; the interest rate path can also be adjusted with new data without causing unnecessary turmoil,” Paulson said in a prepared speech. “This helps achieve price stability and full employment.”

Communication Problems Under Walsh: Avoiding Forward-Looking Guidelines Lead to Disputes

Under the leadership of Chairman Kevin Walsh, how the Federal Reserve should communicate with the market has become a hot topic of discussion. Walsh vowed to avoid sending clear signals to financial markets about interest rate trends, commonly referred to as “forward guidance” (forward guidance).

But he was also criticized for his vagueness: outsiders thought he failed to provide enough insight into his own views on the economy, and his silence forced investors to sometimes look for key clues in other policymakers' speeches.

Although Paulson did not name Walsh, he clearly agreed with this view: in a non-crisis period, there is no need to give clear guidelines on interest rate paths. However, she stressed that Federal Reserve officials should fully explain their views so that investors and the public can form a “common understanding of how policymakers will respond to economic conditions” — in monetary policy terms, the “reaction function” (reaction function) of policymakers.

“In normal times, guidance on interest rate paths is less valuable because as long as people understand the response function, they can usually calculate the path themselves,” she said.

Support staying on hold last month: a common understanding so that “pause” is not misinterpreted as “stop”

As a member with the right to vote on monetary policy this year, Paulson said she supported last month's decision to keep interest rates unchanged and attributed the results to communication.

“The reason why such a suspension works best is because the policy direction is fully understood,” she said. As investors have anticipated further policy tightening, this decision has not left the policy behind the situation.” A common understanding of the response function enabled the policy to proceed calmly and gave all parties time to make adjustments — while avoiding the risk of misinterpreting the suspension as a stop.”

Investors currently expect the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates in December and January next year, and the third rate hike is expected to arrive in April next year. The minutes of the October meeting show that almost all officials believe interest rates may have to be raised in the coming months.

In recent days, many policymakers have spoken out about economic prospects and interest rate paths. Paulson has always advocated “gradual tightening,” but Governor Christopher Waller and other officials have warned that interest rates may be raised by 50 basis points next month.

Supporting multi-channel communication: bitmaps are “useful at certain times”

Paulson also acknowledged the Federal Reserve's efforts in transparency in recent decades and supported maintaining diverse communication channels — including a quarterly “dot plot” (dot plot) of interest rate forecasts published by the Federal Reserve.

“I think bitmaps are very useful in some periods and not so useful in others,” she said. “That's why we value multiple communication methods — because at least at any point in time, one of them is always working.”

What is alarming is that as part of the central bank's reform agenda, Walsh has set up five working groups to study key aspects of the Federal Reserve's internal operations, from balance sheets to communication strategies. Walsh himself did not submit bitmap interest rate forecasts, nor has he promised to hold further press conferences after this year — outsiders are concerned that these two practices may be abolished.