Cathay Pacific Haitong: The retail sector is seasonally concentrated, and major market conditions in the second half of the year need to be driven by multiple factors

Zhitongcaijing · 1d ago

The Zhitong Finance App learned that Cathay Pacific Haitong released a research report saying that the retail sector's seasonal concentration was not uniform in the second half of the year: November was the only month with positive earnings for five consecutive years and surpassed the Shanghai and Shenzhen 300 for five consecutive years (general retail average +8.7%); the review shows that the fundamentals of the traditional retail sector are still under pressure. The market is priced by consumer promotion policies and marginal changes in individual stocks & sectors, and major markets are usually driven by multiple factors such as “marginal changes in individual stocks themselves and favorable national policies”.

Cathay Pacific Haitong's main views are as follows:

Historical review

The monthly win rate and excess of the General Retail (Shenwan) Index rose significantly in the three windows of July, November, and December. In the first half of the year, it generally outperformed the Shanghai and Shenzhen 300, with January and June being the weakest; November was the only month with positive earnings for five consecutive years and surpassing the Shanghai and Shenzhen 300 for five consecutive years. Based on the average caliber of each sub-sector, the general retail (Shenwan) index achieved an average monthly increase of 8.7% in November from 2021 to 2025, exceeding the Shanghai and Shenzhen 300 index by an average of 7.8%; the department store (Shenwan) index had positive earnings for 4 consecutive years in 2021-2025, surpassing the Shanghai and Shenzhen 300 for 5 consecutive years, with an average increase of 14.3% and an average excess of 13.4% in 2021-2025.

This seasonality is not driven by valuations or fundamentals, but by expectations of marginal changes

As the longest performance vacuum period of the year, the fourth quarter also coincides with the traditional peak consumption season at the end of the year and new year. The bank believes that the market is concerned about peak season data performance, as well as policy settings and possible incremental measures to promote consumption (consumer vouchers, trade-in, etc.) at the December Politburo meeting and the Central Economic Work Conference, and the impact of such policies on sales is usually reflected earlier and more directly in business formats such as department stores and supermarkets.

The fundamentals of traditional retail are still under pressure, and no inflection point has yet appeared

From January to September 2026, the growth rate was only +1.1% year-on-year, and department stores and specialty stores continued to be under pressure; the supermarket (Shenwan) sector had negative revenue growth for three consecutive years from 2023 to 2025, negative for five consecutive years from 2021 to 2025, and negative for four consecutive years from 2022 to 2025. The divergence between fundamentals and stock prices means that the market is priced from marginal changes rather than profit trends, but a single catalyst is often not enough — Yonghui Supermarket officially announced a “fat reform” at the end of May 2024 until the opening of the first store on June 19, up more than 20% in more than half a month; “924” superimposed Mingchuang Premium shares to the peak of the market in mid-December, with a range increase of more than 200%, yet the reporting terminal did not reflect substantial performance improvements brought about by the correction during the same period. The stock prices of Zhongbai Group and BBK did not respond at the beginning of the “fat reform”. Zhongbai Group did not rely on “924" + Wusanglian's competitive restructuring expectations + initial economic multi-factor resonance surged 216% in a single month (falling 33.6% in January of the following year). Backgao's most significant catalyst was “cap removal” in April 2025 (+56% in that month); Chongqing Department Store and Dajishang shares, which had no significant marginal catalysis, had limited stock price response after the correction incident.

Individual stock elasticity is concentrated on a few “shell attributes+event catalysis” targets

Among the top 20 gainers in the fourth quarter of the 2016 to 2025 calendar year, 2016 Q4 Sanjiang Shopping (Alibaba shares), 2019 Q4 Nanning Department Store (change of control), 2024Q4 Zhongbai Group (Wusanglian interindustry competition and restructuring expectations), and 2025Q4 Dongbai Group (Fujian cross-strait policy) all rose by more than 100% in a single quarter; Zhejiang Dongri led the list 7 times. Ningbo Zhongbai and Xinhao appeared 6 times each, and the top 20 were highly repeated, indicating that opportunities in this window are more dependent on regional state-owned assets background, small market value and restructuring expectations, not the business climate.

Risk warning: Consumption power is declining, industry competition is intensifying, and policy implementation falls short of expectations.