Civil Commerce Innovation and Technology (01632): The Listing Review Committee decided to maintain the decision that it is no longer suitable for listing and continues to suspend trading

Zhitongcaijing · 1d ago

Zhitong Finance App News, Minshang Innovation & Technology (01632) issued an announcement. On November 13, 2026, the Company received a letter from the Stock Exchange (this letter), which stated that after careful consideration of all information submitted by the Company and the Listing Division, the Listing Review Committee decided to uphold the Listing Committee's decision that comprehensive accounting constituted an arrangement aimed at circumventing the reverse takeover rules and the new listing requirements under Chapter 8 of the Listing Rules to achieve a backdoor listing. Due to the Company's failure to comply with the relevant requirements, the Listing Review Committee decided to uphold the Listing Committee's decision that the Company is no longer suitable for listing and to suspend trading of the Company's shares in accordance with section 6.01 (4) of the Listing Rules.

In making its decision, the Listing Review Committee considered the following reasons (excerpted from this letter):

1. The Listing Review Committee accepted the Listing Division's statement that the arrangements should be assessed on the basis that substance prevails over form. Although the Company did not pay the price for increasing control over Minshanghui, the effect of amending the Minshang Wisdom Organization's Articles of Association has enabled the Company to control and comprehensively account for a business that far exceeds that of the Company's IT solutions business. As a result, the arrangement achieved the same substantive result as the Company's acquisition of Minshang Zhihui.

2. Immediately prior to the consolidated account, the Company had an IT solutions business (i.e. the sole revenue-generating business) operated on a very small scale and generated only HK$0.2 million in revenue for the full year of fiscal year 2025. In contrast, the Group's revenue for the six-month financial period ended September 30, 2025 increased to HK$19.4 million. As stated by the Company, this revenue came entirely from Minshang Intelligence and was generated within a period of only two months after the consolidated accounts were recorded.

3. The Listing Review Committee did not accept the Company's argument that Minshang Wisdom is a continuation of the IT solutions business because there is a significant difference between Minshang Wisdom's business model and the IT solutions business model. In particular, the Listing Review Committee noted that most of the revenue from Minshang Wisdom comes from product sales rather than platform fees. The Listing Review Committee also notes that the Company has no dispute with the Listing Division's statement that Civil and Commercial Intelligence did not meet the new listing requirements.

4. Therefore, the Listing Review Committee agreed with the Listing Committee's decision that comprehensive accounting constituted an arrangement to achieve a commercial smart backdoor listing.

5. As far as communication between the Company and the Listing Division is concerned, the Listing Review Committee notes that the Company has stated that it has proposed comprehensive accounting with the listing department, and believes that the listing department has no objections to the consolidated account. In the absence of documentary evidence relating to the discussions at the meeting, the Listing Review Committee will not express an opinion on the content of such discussions. However, the Listing Review Committee notes that in the letter explaining the requirements issued by the Listing Division, the Listing Division also raised concerns that the Company may violate reverse takeover rules when selling the restaurant business and acquiring the scenario Vientiane (Beijing) Technology Co., Ltd. to the Company. The Company further acknowledged that its financial advisors had alerted it to reverse takeover issues that might arise from consolidated accounts. Accordingly, the Listing Review Committee believes that the Company is aware of the reverse takeover as a potential issue to be resolved.

As the Listing Review Committee determined that the consolidated entry constituted a violation of the reverse takeover rules, it agreed that the Listing Division should exercise its powers under section 2.04 of the Listing Rules to impose additional conditions, namely treating the Company as a new listing applicant and requiring it to comply with the additional reverse takeover requirements (including the new listing requirements) under sections 14.54 to 14.57 of the Listing Rules. Due to the Company's failure to comply with the relevant requirements, the Listing Review Committee concluded that the Company is no longer suitable for listing and that trading of the Company's shares should be suspended in accordance with section 6.01 (4) of the Listing Rules after the consolidated account entry.

Since trading of the Company's shares has been suspended since July 2, 2026 due to failure to publish its annual results for the financial year ending March 31, 2026, the Company must reach any resumption guidelines set by the Stock Exchange before January 1, 2028, and fully comply with the listing rules until the Exchange is satisfied. According to Rule 6.01A (1) of the Listing Rules, the Stock Exchange may cancel the listing status of the Company's shares if trading is suspended for 18 consecutive months.

Furthermore, trading of the company's shares continues to be suspended.