Kerui Real Estate Research: Housing markets in 15 key cities stabilized in October, but restoration still relies on price for volume and low base effects

Zhitongcaijing · 3d ago

The Zhitong Finance App learned that in October 2026, Kerui Real Estate Research published an article stating that in October 2026, the housing market in key cities showed operating characteristics of “falling high supply levels, continuing to rise in new homes, and a month-on-month increase in second-hand” under the “Silver Ten” window. The supply of new housing declined sharply after centralized sales in September. Transactions continued the month-on-month repair trend, and the year-on-year decline narrowed further; second-hand housing increased month-on-month, supported by a low base in the same month last year, and the year-on-year increase expanded markedly. The simultaneous recovery in second-hand transactions led to a year-on-year correction in total volume, and overall elimination pressure eased marginally. Overall, the market stabilized in October in stages under “contraction of supply and elimination of stocks,” but the recovery still depended on exchanging price for volume and low base effects.

01 Overall overview: The total number of second-hand goods continued to rise month-on-month and corrected year-on-year, and the share of second-hand fell back to 66.77%

In October 2026, the total volume of housing market (new building+used) transactions in 14 key cities was about 19.2691 million square meters, up 4.70% from the previous month. The growth rate was 2.86 percentage points higher than the previous month; the year-on-year increase was 9.50%, which was corrected from a decrease of 0.52% last month. Among them, new commercial residential transactions were 6.4037 million square meters, up 8.32% month-on-month, down 7.85%; second-hand residential transactions were 12.8654 million square meters, up 2.99% month-on-month and 20.82% year-on-year. Overall, the year-on-year change in total volume was mainly driven by second-hand housing. Second-hand housing increased sharply year-on-year under last year's low base, effectively hedging the year-on-year decline in new housing.

At the structural level, the share of second-hand housing transactions in 14 cities fell back to 66.77%, down 1.11 percentage points from September. The month-on-month recovery in new housing transactions led to phased restoration, but the share of second-hand housing is still close to 70%. The scale of second-hand housing transactions is about 2.0 times that of new housing, and the overall pattern dominated by the stock market has not changed.

pictures

Figure 1 Trends in the transaction area of newly built and second-hand housing in 14 key cities across the country from January 2025 to October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

Scope of 14 cities: Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Chengdu, Xi'an, Wuhan, Tianjin, Nanjing, Suzhou, Chongqing, Changsha, and Foshan.

02 Newly built commercial housing market: supply plummeted by 63.60% month-on-month, and the year-on-year decline in transactions narrowed to 8.17%

Overall supply and demand: supply declined seasonally, transactions continued to rise month-on-month, and the supply-demand ratio fell to 0.55

In October, the high supply of newly built commercial housing in 15 cities declined, and transactions continued to recover. The monthly supply-demand ratio fell to 0.55 from 1.64 last month.

The supply side declined markedly after centralized sales in September, which is the most prominent marginal change in the new housing market this month. According to CRIC monitoring, the supply of newly built commercial residential buildings in October 15 was increased by 3.631,300 square meters, a sharp drop of 63.60% from the previous month and 20.01% from the previous year. The cliff-style decline in supply was mainly due to the high base of centralized evidence collection in September and the active adjustment of housing companies' year-end sales under “sales to determine production.” On a cumulative basis, from January to October 2026, 15 cities supplied a total of 498.728 million square meters, a cumulative year-on-year decrease of 18.43%. The decline was 0.13 percentage points higher than in January-September, and the supply contraction trend remained unchanged throughout the year.

The fall in supply did not affect the repair at the transaction end. In October 15, new commercial residential transactions were 6.574,600 square meters, an increase of 7.76% over the previous month, achieving positive growth for two consecutive months; the year-on-year decline was 8.17%, and the decline was 2.04 percentage points narrower than the previous month. The support mainly comes from the continuous transformation of sellable goods volume formed by evidence collection in September, and the centralized filing of low total price projects in some cities under the “interest rate discount” policy. On a cumulative basis, the total transaction volume of 64.8076 million square meters in January-October was 64.8076 million square meters, a cumulative year-on-year decrease of 11.23%. The decline was 0.33 percentage points narrower than in January-September, reflecting that demand-side repair momentum is still weak.

There was a clear correction on the price side. The average transaction price of newly built commercial residential buildings in October 15 was 27,879 yuan/square meter, down 5.40% from the previous month, down 6.35 percentage points from the previous month; up 4.00% year on year, up 0.32 percentage points from the previous month. Average prices fell month-on-month, mainly due to the structural impact of the increase in the share of transactions in low-cost cities; the year-on-year increase remained positive, indicating that high-end project filings in core cities still supported prices, but “price in exchange for volume” is still the main means of elimination in most cities, and the signs of overall price stabilization are still unclear.

pictures

Figure 2 Supply and demand volume and price trends of newly built commercial housing in 15 key cities across the country from January 2025 to October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System; Statistical Caliber: Commercial housing, including residences, villas, and serviced apartments.

Scope of 15 cities: Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, Chengdu, Xi'an, Wuhan, Tianjin, Nanjing, Suzhou, Chongqing, Hefei, Changsha, and Foshan.

From a city perspective, the leading pattern of transactions in the city changed markedly on October 15. Chongqing took the lead with 732,000 square meters, an increase of 25.36% over the previous month. Guangzhou (646,900 square meters) and Chengdu (631,200 square meters) followed, while Tianjin (605,000 square meters) and Wuhan (581,500 square meters) also remained above 550,000 square meters. The overall ranking of leading cities rose from last month.

pictures

Figure 3 Supply and demand volume and price performance of newly built commercial housing in 15 key cities across the country in October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

The year-on-year performance differentiation remained the same. Six of the 15 cities achieved positive year-on-year growth: Beijing (+36.65%) had the highest increase, while Wuhan (+9.48%), Shanghai (+8.26%), Shenzhen (+2.04%), Guangzhou (+1.35%), and Nanjing (+1.31%) were increasing slightly, showing the resilience of first-tier cities. Among the declining cities, Changsha (-54.52%) saw the deepest decline, while Xi'an (-22.74%), Chengdu (-21.60%), and Hefei (-18.60%) also fell close to or more than 20%, while Chongqing (-14.20%) and Suzhou (-14.28%) also fell by more than 10%.

On a month-on-month basis, 10 out of 15 cities achieved positive growth, and the stabilization level contracted compared to the previous month. Foshan led the rise with 43.55%, followed by Chongqing (+25.36%), Suzhou (+23.51%), Wuhan (+19.12%), and Changsha (+18.69%). Guangzhou, Chengdu, Shenzhen, Hangzhou, and Tianjin all maintained positive growth within 10%. The five cities of Beijing (-1.67%), Nanjing (-3.91%), Xi'an (-4.64%), Shanghai (-7.53%), and Hefei (-9.75%) declined month-on-month, with generally moderate declines.

Looking at the volume price bureau, the average transaction price in Shanghai was 75,781 yuan/square meter, Shenzhen 57,770 yuan/square meter, and Beijing 56,979 yuan/square meter, still forming the first tier of prices; Hangzhou ranked first in the second tier with 40,277 yuan/square meter. Among them, Shanghai “reduced volume and price increased”, with an average price increase of 2.45% month-on-month, but it was still the biggest drop among the four first-tier cities. The impact of the high-end market filing pace is still there; Wuhan (+15.51%) and Changsha (+33.58%) respectively led month-on-month increases, mainly affected by the low base and product structure. The average price in Chongqing was only 8,209 yuan/square meter, down 6.36% month-on-month and 15.44% year-on-year, continuing the “price for volume” characteristic.

Table 1. Transaction area and changes of newly built commercial housing in 15 key cities across the country in October 2026 (unit: 10,000 square meters)

pictures

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

Transaction structure: The main position of 90-130㎡ rebounded to 53.08%, and the share below 90㎡ fell to 17.83%

In October, the transaction structure of newly built commercial housing in 15 cities showed marginal changes in “just a decline in demand and a recovery in the main position”. According to CRIC monitoring, the number of units sold under 90㎡ accounted for 17.83%, down 3.81 percentage points from September; 90-110㎡ accounted for 27.38%, an increase of 2.34 percentage points, the biggest increase in each segment (mainly affected by interest rate coverage); 110-130㎡ accounted for 25.70%, an increase of 1.02 percentage points; 130-150㎡ accounted for 17.80%, an increase of 0.55 percentage points; the share of 150㎡ and above was 11.30%, which is basically the same as last month. The total share of 90-130 square meters was 53.08%, up 3.36 percentage points from 49.72% in September, and regained more than 50%.

Looking at the longer cycle, the total area area of 90-130 square meters accounted for 53.08%, an increase of 3.93 percentage points over the same period last year (49.15%), and the area center moved slightly upward. By structure, compared with the same period last year, 90-110 square meters increased by 2.77 percentage points, 110-130 square meters increased by 1.16 percentage points, while 90 square meters or less decreased by 1.55 percentage points, 130-150 square meters decreased by 0.25 percentage points, and above 150 square meters decreased by 2.13 percentage points. The share of demand, which rose briefly last month, did not continue. The focus of transactions returned to the 90-130 square meter main range in October, which is not only related to the rebound in the share of first modified products in the supply structure during the month, but also confirms the demand structure of the “central area segment is the basic market” under total price constraints. Improved demand is still resilient purchasing power.

pictures

Figure 4 Changes in the proportion of newly built commercial residential units sold by area in 15 key cities across the country from January 2025 to October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

By city, there are large differences in the transaction structure of each area segment, and it is closely related to the city's energy level, housing price level, and supply and demand structure.

Among the first-tier cities, Shenzhen accounted for 48.11% of the 90㎡ or less, and Guangzhou was 36.22%. The characteristics of needing small apartments under high housing prices continued, but the two cities fell 0.84 and 9.25 percentage points, respectively, compared to the previous month. Among them, Guangzhou declined significantly, which is related to the high base of inventory records just last month. The highest proportion of 90-110 square meters in Beijing was 32.15%, and 130-150 square meters increased by 3.41 percentage points to 13.37%. The share of 90 square meters or less in Shanghai is 7.82%, the lowest in the four cities; 90-110 square meters rose to 43.95% (+4.49 percentage points), the highest among the four cities; 150 square meters or more fell to 14.85%, and the share of high-end areas fell back but remained a certain volume.

Among second- and third-tier cities, Changsha accounts for 36.55% of 110-130㎡ and 33.68% of 130-150㎡; the total share of medium and large apartments still accounts for 70.23%, and the preference for large units under low housing prices is further strengthened; Suzhou accounts for 24.43% of 150 square meters and 23.75% of 130-150 square meters, and the improvement ratio is still at the forefront; Hangzhou accounts for 25.68%, and high-end improvement demand remains resilient; Xi'an 130-150 accounts for 30.28%, 110-130㎡ 30.36%, medium and large apartments predominate overall. 90 Below square meters, only 3.96%, and the dominant pattern of improvement continues. It is worth noting that the share of 150 square meters or more in Hefei rose to 19.30%, falling below 90 square meters to 5.82%, and the structure clearly leaned towards the improvement end; Tianjin dropped from 33.28% to 20.67% (-12.61 percentage points) below 90 square meters, and the structure changed from first place to first.

Table 2 Percentage of newly built commercial residential units sold by area in 15 key cities across the country in October 2026

pictures

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

Note: Percentages are rounded off by item, and the total may not equal 100%.

Inventory removal: Inventory fell 1.10% month-on-month, and the removal cycle remained stable at 23.3 months

In October, inventories of newly built commercial residential homes in 15 cities returned to a downward channel as supply contracted, and the removal cycle remained the same as last month. According to CRIC monitoring, as of the end of October, the inventory area of newly built commercial housing in 15 cities was 152.910,000 square meters, down 1.10% from the previous month and 1.85% from the previous year; the removal cycle was 23.3 months, the same as in September, and 4.5 months longer than the same period last year (18.8 months). Inventories ended a brief recovery in September and returned to the downward channel of fluctuation since May, mainly due to a fall in high supply levels and significantly less new supply than transactions in the same month. The phased improvement in the supply-demand ratio eased marginal pressure compared to the previous month, but the absolute inventory size was still at a high level of 153 million square meters, and the removal cycle is still at a high level in recent years.

pictures

Figure 5 Changes in the inventory and removal cycle of newly built commercial housing in 15 key cities across the country from January 2025 to October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

The pattern of de-fragmentation between cities is generally stable. Hangzhou (11.1 months), Chongqing (11.8 months), and Hefei (13.3 months) are below the 18-month warning line and are in the relative health range; Shanghai (18.6 months), Tianjin (19.6 months), Shenzhen (23.0 months), Xi'an (23.5 months), Guangzhou (24.7 months), Changsha (25.4 months), Nanjing (26.0 months), Wuhan (27.7 months), Beijing (28.5 months), Jiucheng is in the 18-30 month decompression range; Suzhou (30.5 months), and 32.5 months (Foshan) 2 months), The decontamination cycle in the three cities of Chengdu (35.4 months) exceeds 30 months, and the risk of inventory precipitation has yet to be resolved. Beijing fell back from 30.1 months to 28.5 months.

It is worth noting that Chengdu has an inventory area of 237.867 million square meters, ranking first among the 15 cities. The removal cycle was 0.4 to 35.4 months longer than the previous month; in that month, Chengdu supplied 313,500 square meters, with a ratio of 0.50 between supply and demand. The supply rhythm has clearly subsided, but it will still take time to digest the backlog in the early stages. The ratio between supply and demand in Hangzhou was 0.94, and the supply and transaction period remained in a relatively healthy range; the supply-demand ratio in Chongqing and Foshan was only 0.12 and 0.13. The “production based on sales” characteristic is extreme, which is conducive to inventory clearance in the short term, but it also lays the groundwork for a rebound in supply at the end of the fourth quarter.

pictures

Figure 6 Cross-analysis of supply, demand and removal of newly built commercial housing in 15 key national cities in October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

Note: The bubble size represents the inventory area.

Project performance: Beijing took half of the seats in the money list, and both sides of the area list went hand in hand

Judging from the top 10 projects in terms of transaction area, the distribution of leading project cities was clearly scattered compared to last month. Eight cities of Chengdu, Beijing, Tianjin, Changsha, Guangzhou, Suzhou, Hangzhou, and Foshan all entered the list, with Beijing dominating 3 seats. Chengdu Chengjin Jinyuwan led with 41,700 square meters, with an average transaction price of only 7,398 yuan/square meter; Beijing Shoukai Co., Ltd. Xiyue Jingyan (36,900 square meters) and Tianjin Fusheng Gongyuan Lefu (31,900 square meters) ranked second and third. Among them, Fusheng Gongyuan Lefu had an average transaction price of only 4,811 yuan/square meter, which is a typical low total price movement project. The total transaction area of the TOP10 was 296,300 square meters, amounting to 9.545 billion yuan, and the average unit area was 117.8 square meters. This is a sharp increase from September (88.0 square meters). The low price market and the high unit price improvement market coexist.

Table 3 Top 10 sales area of newly built commercial residential projects in 15 key cities across the country in October 2026

pictures

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

The top 10 turnover continues the distinct “high-end improvement of core cities” characteristics. Beijing has 5 seats, Shanghai has 3 seats, and Hangzhou has 2 seats. First-tier cities occupy a total of 8 seats. At the top of the list was Beijing Yu Hai Song, with a turnover of 3.122 billion yuan and an average price of 106,140 yuan/square meter; followed by Shanghai Huarun Qiqibinjiang (1,736 billion yuan) and Hangzhou Greentown Fontan Rose Garden (1,587 billion yuan). The total amount of the TOP10 is 15.823 billion yuan, of which the average price of 4 projects exceeds 100,000 yuan/square meter. The asset allocation needs of high-net-worth people continue to support the independent market in the high-end market in core cities; traders are mainly central state-owned enterprises and leading housing enterprises such as Start-up, China Investment, Greentown, China Construction, etc., and industry concentration continues to rise.

Table 4 Top 10 sales value of newly built commercial residential projects in 15 key cities across the country in October 2026

pictures

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

03 Stock commercial housing market: transactions increased 2.99% month-on-month, and the year-on-year increase expanded to 20.82% under a low base

Total transaction volume: 12.87 million square meters in a single month, ending five consecutive month-on-month declines, with a significant year-on-year increase

The total transaction area of second-hand housing in 14 key cities in October was 12.8654 million square meters, up 2.99% month-on-month, ending the five-month month-on-month decline since May; the year-on-year increase was 20.82%, up 15.48 percentage points from September, the highest in a single month since 2026. The year-on-year increase was mainly affected by the low base for the same month last year. From January to October, a total of 135.55,500 square meters were sold, with a cumulative year-on-year increase of 7.04%. The growth rate was 1.26 percentage points higher than in January-September, and the momentum of second-hand housing continued to recover.

Judging from the quantitative energy trend, second-hand housing transactions declined month by month after rising to 166.397 million square meters in April. The month-on-month decline in May-September was suspended for five consecutive months, and the month-on-month increase and decline in October was suspended. Second-hand housing picked up at the same time this month, but the month-on-month growth rate of new homes was higher than that of second-hand homes, and it led for two consecutive months, indicating that some demand under the “Silver Ten” window is phased back into the new housing market. However, the year-on-year increase in second-hand housing is still significantly higher than that of new homes, and the overall pattern of “strong second-hand and weak new homes” has not changed.

pictures

Figure 7 Changes in second-hand housing transaction area in 14 key national cities from January 2025 to October 2026

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

City performance: Shanghai and Rong continued to lead, with positive overall year-on-year growth in 14 cities

By city, in terms of transaction volume, Shanghai continued to lead with 1.863,500 square meters, followed by Chengdu with 1.592,600 square meters. Beijing (1,147,700 square meters) and Tianjin (1,089,600 square meters) maintain a size of more than 1 million square meters, while Wuhan (944,400 square meters), Xi'an (926,900 square meters), and Guangzhou (844,400 square meters) are in the second tier; Hangzhou (659,700 square meters) overtook Suzhou and Nanjing to ninth place, and Shenzhen (454,800 square meters) was relatively far behind in size.

In terms of year-over-year performance, all 14 cities achieved positive growth. Suzhou led the way with an increase of 39.40%, with cities such as Shanghai (+33.15%), Wuhan (+30.39%), and Tianjin (+29.42%) growing by about 30%; Shenzhen (+3.14%) and Beijing (+5.26%) saw relatively moderate increases. It should be pointed out that the overall correction was mainly affected by the low base for the same month last year. Hangzhou (-5.27%), Chongqing (-3.25%), and Guangzhou (-0.25%) still showed negative growth under the cumulative scale.

On a month-on-month basis, 10 out of 14 cities achieved positive growth, and the area of recovery increased markedly. Chongqing led the month-on-month increase of 11.81%. Changsha (+11.70%), Chengdu (+10.17%), Guangzhou (+9.62%), Tianjin (+8.45%), Shanghai (+8.18%), and Hangzhou (+8.13%) all increased by more than 8%, while Wuhan (+6.27%), Xi'an (+5.24%), and Shenzhen (+5.24%) rebounded steadily. The four cities of Beijing (-16.72%), Nanjing (-15.41%), Suzhou (-8.26%), and Foshan (-2.04%) declined month-on-month. Among them, Beijing and Nanjing declined significantly, or were related to the phased decline after the release of demand in the early stages.

Table 5 Changes in second-hand housing transaction area in 14 key cities across the country in October 2026 (unit: 10,000 square meters)

pictures

Data source: CRIC China Real Estate Decision Consulting System.

04 Future market outlook: low supply operation, transaction repair continues, kinetic energy switching is still awaiting confirmation on the demand side

Entering November, after “Silver Ten” came to an end, the market entered a transition window before the year-end sprint. There was a possibility of year-end reimbursement after a sharp decline in October, but “production through sales” and financial constraints determined a limited amount of reimbursement; whether the transaction side can continue to recover after two consecutive months of month-on-month recovery depends on the speed of elimination of low total price projects and the release of demand for improvement in core cities; second-hand housing increased or narrowed significantly year-on-year after the low base effect weakened. Whether the market can switch from “month-on-month recovery” to “year-on-year stabilization” in the fourth quarter still depends on substantial improvements in demand-side confidence and the pace of implementation on the policy side.

1. Year-end supply or moderate reimbursement, but the trend of contraction remains unchanged throughout the year. In October, the supply was only 3.631,300 square meters, down 63.60% from the previous month. Most cities have entered the inventory replenishment stage after centralized evidence collection in September. November-December is the target window for housing enterprises to sprint up for the year. Some cities have the possibility of speeding up promotion, but there has been no substantial improvement in funding, and “using sales to determine production” still limits volume. Supply is expected to pick up month-on-month in November and continue to grow negatively year-on-year, making it difficult to reverse the trend of supply contraction throughout the year.

2. The year-on-year decline in new housing transactions is expected to narrow or even correct, with a month-on-month increase and then decline. The transaction base for November and December 15 of last year was 6.244,400 square meters and 7.845,600 square meters respectively. Of these, the November base was low during the year. If November transactions remained generally flat month-on-month, the year-on-year period is expected to improve; the December base rose markedly, and the year-on-year basis may be under pressure again. Overall, the center of new housing transactions in the fourth quarter is expected to move higher than in the third quarter, but the level of repair still depends on a substantial improvement in demand-side confidence.

3. Urban differentiation continues, and the risk of eliminating severe urban areas needs to be solved. Cities such as Beijing, Shanghai, and Wuhan have strong year-on-year resilience, and restoration momentum is relatively superior; in cities where the year-on-year decline is still deep, demand overdrafts and supply adjustments coexist; the removal cycle of Suzhou, Foshan, and Chengdu still exceeds 30 months, and “price-for-volume” is still progressing simultaneously with inventory clearance in the fourth quarter, and the price pressure in severely degraded cities will still be higher than the average of 15 cities.

4. The second-hand housing market volume stabilized at a high level, and the year-on-year increase in November may have narrowed significantly. The month-on-month increase in second-hand housing in October was mainly supported by a low base. In November of last year, the second-hand transaction base rose to 12.1251,000 square meters. If November transactions remained roughly the same as current volume, the year-on-year increase or narrowed to single digits.