1 Options Trade to Bet on Cisco Stock Ahead of Earnings on November 12 — and Get a Shot at a 128.57% Maximum Payout

Barchart · 11/09 09:31

If we look at Cisco Systems (CSCO) strictly from a “data nerd” perspective, there may be a statistical likelihood that CSCO stock may move higher within the near-term time period. Of course, if we were simply placing a binary bet that the security will move higher from the current spot price, that might be an incredibly straightforward wager.

Unfortunately, the options market isn’t in the business of providing easy wagers.

Let’s lay down what we know. In the past 30 days, Cisco stock dropped nearly 21% due to macroeconomic concerns that have weighed heavily on artificial intelligence and related infrastructures. Naturally, the red ink imposed a penalty on CSCO’s chart performance, causing the ticker to incur a 56% Sell rating from the Barchart Technical Opinion indicator.

On a conceptual note, the fallout presents a tempting proposition for contrarian options traders. As one of the giants in network infrastructure, Cisco’s ever-growing relevance underpins capital inflows into CSCO stock. Therefore, mean reversion isn’t just a random idea — it has real plausibility for a name like Cisco.

This observation leads to another fact: whenever the number of positive weekly candlesticks greatly outnumbers negative candlesticks over a rolling 10-week period, the historical tendency is for CSCO stock to rise higher than the random aggregate performance of any 10-week period (going back to the last five years).

Simply put, the observation of historical data suggests that there is typically a transition from an extremely bearish state to a future bullish state. In this particular circumstance — where Cisco stock has printed only three up weeks within a 10-week period — the probability of the ticker hitting the psychological target of $100 over the next five weeks is estimated at 46.7%.

From here, the narrative gets tricky.

CSCO Stock for the December Monthly Isn’t a Good Deal

If we wanted to speculate on the above observation — that Cisco stock tends to transition from bearish to bullish states — the December monthly options chain (expiring Dec. 18) would presumably give us plenty of time. However, bull call spreads for that expiration period featuring a second-leg strike price of $100 only provide a maximum payout of 96.08% at time of writing.

From an expected value (EV) perspective, that’s going to put our debit-based transaction into negative expectancy. I’m not saying that this idea is irrational as “rationality” is a philosophically relative term; what’s rational to one person may be utterly bonkers to another. But if we both agree to use EV as a standard of rationality, then under that specific condition, the December monthly is not a good deal.

Shall we then extend the expiration date further out? That would lower time risk but would greatly escalate event risk — or the risk that plenty of stuff can happen between now and the January monthly chain. And because CSCO stock is such a stout investment overall, the market’s expectation is for the security to recover by then. Subsequently, the payout for reaching $100 will be even lower, creating an even more negative expectancy.

It stinks but arguably, the more rational approach here is to consider the upcoming November monthly, which is only two weeks away. This reduces event risk (since there’s less room for multiple variable events to materialize) at the expense of exponentially higher time risk.

However, the nuance here is the fiscal-first-quarter earnings disclosure scheduled for Nov. 12.

Is a Potential Upshot in the Works for Cisco Stock?

Right now, Barchart has the implied volatility (IV) for the November monthly chain at 73.41%. That’s significant because the historical volatility reading for the period is only 38.92%. In other words, under baseline conditions, a standard bullish environment would likely have CSCO stock gradually drift higher. We’re talking about a stock that features a 60-month beta of 1.01 — very much characteristic of a blue chip.

Obviously, anticipation is rising sharply ahead of the company’s Q1 earnings report. Now, a high IV doesn’t necessarily mean that CSCO stock will move northward; the volatility could just as easily send the ticker crashing down, particularly if results and/or guidance don’t exceed the market’s expectations.

Still, the contrarian viewpoint is as follows. Because Cisco stock has already incurred a heavy beatdown, it may only take a relatively small unit of good news to have a disproportionately positive impact on CSCO.

As for my personal speculation on the matter, I mentioned that Cisco’s transitional dynamics lead to an estimated probability of 46.7% that CSCO stock will hit $100 over the next five weeks. It’s possible, then, that this inferred move could occur over the next two weeks thanks to the potential earnings catalyst.

If you want to take a speculative shot, you may consider the 96/100 bull call spread expiring Nov. 20. With a maximum payout of 128.57% stemming from a $175 net debit, your EV would come out to $11.80 or a return on capital of +6.74%.

Granted, that’s not the most attractive wager but it would keep you out of negative expectancy.


On the date of publication, Josh Enomoto did not directly have a position in any of the securities mentioned in this article. All information and data in this article is solely for informational purposes. For more information please view the Barchart Disclosure Policy here.