The Bet Behind Nutrien's Rally

If Nutrien sat on a watchlist instead of in a portfolio, the outcome over the past 12 months may feel like a missed call. For Nutrien shareholders, the return over the past year was 32.7%, including dividends. The question is what, if anything, in late 2025 could have helped you spot that potential, especially the assumption that tight fertilizer supply and strong global food demand would support its potash and nitrogen business before the later earnings beats arrived.

If the move has made Nutrien harder to judge, start where the gap is still open and scan 4 high quality undervalued stocks.

The Two Stories Nutrien Investors Had To Weigh

The shares cost CA$76.68 at the start of the period, and Nutrien sat between two very different stories about where fertilizer demand and costs might go next.

On the optimistic side, the bull Narrative saw strong global food demand and precision agriculture supporting fertilizer use. This view implied a Fair Value of CA$85.56, a price level that relied on tighter supply and operational efficiencies to support margins.

The more cautious bear Narrative pointed to rising regulations and carbon costs as a squeeze on profitability. This view implied a Fair Value of CA$62.24 that rested on the risk of biological alternatives and sustainable farming reducing long term demand for conventional fertilizer products.

What The Nutrien Results Put To The Test

Record potash volumes and higher fertilizer prices in early 2026 backed the optimistic Nutrien story that strong nutrient demand could support sales. Later results showed revenue at US$10,609m versus US$10,198m and net income at US$1,214m versus US$1,221m, with net margin slipping from 12.0% to 11.4%. The evidence cut both ways.

The real hinge was not demand; it was profitability. For similar stocks, check whether higher volumes and pricing actually show up in net income and margin rather than assuming the story flows straight through.

What Nutrien's Current Price Already Bakes In

Nutrien now trades at CA$97.07 after a 32.7% gain over the past year. The selected Narrative places its Fair Value above that level, framing the current quote as not fully reflecting its thesis.

The focus is on nitrogen tightness, portfolio reshaping and higher margin proprietary products as the key earnings drivers. A buyer today would need to judge whether Nutrien can keep shifting its mix toward those higher value offerings while holding capital and overhead discipline.

"Bullish analysts expect Nutrien to use its record potash sales, low controllable cash costs, and mapped capacity expansion plan to turn its asset base into a long-term volume and margin growth engine as global demand for potash continues to build. The main condition is that Nutrien successfully executes its portfolio pruning and mix shift toward higher-margin proprietary and specialty products while keeping capital expenditures and SG&A within the tighter framework management has outlined."

The price and this Narrative do not agree. → Uncover what this Narrative says Nutrien is actually worth

Looking One Step Beyond Nutrien

Nutrien highlights how critical potash can be to food security. Once you see that, it is natural to ask where new supply might come from.

Some producers are testing ways to pull potash from the ground without the usual giant shafts and tunnels. They lean on horizontal drilling methods, adapted from oilfields, to reach the ore body.

Fluid is circulated to dissolve the mineral underground, then brought up and crystallized at the surface. That design aims to cut capital needs and shorten the path to meaningful output.

The footprint can be smaller, with less surface waste and brine recycled rather than discharged.

If this mining model proves itself at scale, it could change how future potash projects get financed and approved.

That argument has a Narrative and a number behind it. → See the company one Narrative values 54% above its price

Have feedback on this article? Concerned about the content? Get in touch with us directly. Alternatively, email editorial-team@simplywallst.com